Value proposition
Value Proposition Canvas: making offer and customer meet
The Value Proposition Canvas has two halves and six boxes. On the right sits the customer: the jobs they want to get done, the pains that get in the way, the gains they expect. On the left sits your offer: your products and services, the pain relievers, the gain creators. Fit exists when every reliever answers a recorded pain and every creator a recorded gain. The order matters more than the boxes: fill in the right-hand side first, from customer conversations, and only then the left.
What the canvas is for
The canvas comes from Alexander Osterwalder and his co-authors, who published it in 2014 in "Value Proposition Design", the follow-up to the Business Model Canvas. It answers a question the larger canvas leaves open: the Business Model Canvas has one box for customer segments and one for value propositions, and it is precisely those two boxes on which most ideas quietly fail.
The tool takes those two boxes and splits each into three. That sounds like more paperwork and is the opposite: six small boxes force statements specific enough to be wrong, which is what makes them checkable. "Saves time" fits in the large box and survives every review. "Removes two days of downtime per repair" does not survive the first customer conversation if it is not true.
Your offer
The customer
Products & services
Mobile repair at the workplace, fixed time slots
Customer jobs
Get to work every weekday without a car
Pain relievers
Repair during working hours, no downtime
Pains
Two days without a bike, because the shop opens office hours only
Gain creators
Condition report with photo, reminder for the next service
Expected gains
Knowing the bike is safe without having to think about it
Three pairs, read from the right: the customer states a job, a pain and a gain, and your offer answers each one. A left-hand entry without a partner on the right is effort nobody asked for.
The right-hand side: the customer profile
This half comes first, and it does not come from you. Everything here should be traceable to something a real person said. The running example is a mobile bike repair service in Portland.
Customer jobs
What is the customer trying to get done?The practical job is not the only one. Beside it sit the social job (how do they want to be seen) and the emotional one (how do they want to feel). Those two get forgotten almost every time, and they often decide the purchase.
Practical: get to work on time. Social: not be the person whose bike is always broken. Emotional: be able to rely on the bike.
Pains
What annoys, costs or goes wrong?Everything that makes the job harder: lost time, cost, risk, hassle, poor outcomes. Write pains down the way the customer describes them, in their words, and put a number next to them wherever you can.
Two working days without a bike. Shop visits only possible during your own working hours. Price unclear up front.
Expected gains
What would count as a good outcome?Four levels: what is strictly required, what is expected, what is desired, and what would come as a surprise. Deliver only the required and you are interchangeable. Deliver only the surprise and you have usually missed the required.
Required: the bike rides again. Expected: it holds for more than four weeks. Desired: no appointment needed. Surprising: rideable again tonight.
The left-hand side: the value map
This half only opens once the right-hand side is ranked. Every entry here needs a partner over there. That single rule is what stops the canvas from turning into a feature list.
Products & services
What exactly do you offer?The plain list of what the customer receives, physical or digital. This box is the easiest and therefore the most dangerous: it fills up fast and creates the feeling of being finished.
On-site repair, fixed slots at employer sites, loaner bike for larger jobs, maintenance subscription.
Pain relievers
How do you remove that specific pain?For every entry you must be able to name a pain from the right-hand side, otherwise it does not belong here. A reliever that matches no recorded pain is a feature you happen to consider important.
Repair during working hours instead of downtime. Fixed price up front instead of an open invoice.
Gain creators
How do you produce an expected gain?The same on the gain side. This is where the points beyond the strictly required appear, and those are what later carry the price. A gain creator with no matching gain is effort without effect.
Photo report on the state of the bike. Reminder before winter. Safety check at no extra charge.
How to fill it in, in four steps
Around four hours in total, of which two are conversations. Step 2 is the one most people skip, and it is the one that decides whether the canvas produces a decision or a decoration.
Fill the right-hand side, from conversations
2 hours, spread across 8 to 10 conversationsStart with the customer, not with yourself. Ask about the last time the problem came up and have them walk you through it. Write down only what somebody actually said. Anything you add at your desk, mark as an assumption, so you do not later mistake it for a finding.
Result: five to eight jobs, pains and gains each, in the customers' words, with assumptions visibly separated.
Rank the lists
20 minutesSort each of the three lists from top to bottom: how important the job is, how severe the pain, how strongly the gain is expected. Without this step the canvas is a collection. Only the ranking turns it into a decision about what you work on.
Result: the three strongest pains and the two most important gains sit at the top and are marked.
Write the left-hand side against it
60 minutesOnly now your offer, and only in relation to the marked points. Write exactly one reliever per pain and exactly one creator per gain. Anything that belongs to no marked point goes on a side list. That list is not worthless, but it is not the offer.
Result: a left-hand side that answers at most five points, instead of answering everything a little.
Check the fit and mark the gaps
30 minutesGo through it line by line: which pain has no reliever, which service relates to nothing? The first is a gap, the second is idle effort. Both are results, not mistakes. The gaps are your next product decision, the idle items your next deletion list.
Result: a list of open gaps and one to three services you can drop without replacement.
Fit comes in three levels
A filled-in canvas is a proposal, not a proof. It becomes fit in three stages, each with its own evidence, and each one can only be reached after the one before it.
1Problem-solution fit
On paperHow you recognise itCustomers confirm the pains and gains you recorded, without you prompting them.
How you test it8 to 15 conversations about the last concrete incident, not about your idea.
All this proves is that the problem exists. Whether anyone pays for your solution is a separate question.
2Product-market fit
In the marketHow you recognise itCustomers use the offer repeatedly and pay for it. They would be noticeably unhappy if it disappeared tomorrow.
How you test itSell, measure repeat rate and churn, ask non-users why not.
One-off first purchases prove nothing. Repetition is what separates curiosity from need.
3Business model fit
In the numbersHow you recognise itWhat a customer brings in covers the cost of winning them and carries a share of the fixed costs, repeatably.
How you test itContribution margin per customer, acquisition cost, break-even calculation.
An idea can delight every customer and still fail at this level. It is the level that gets checked least often.
The third level in numbers: understanding break-even, with an interactive calculator →
What a good canvas produces
Not a tidy picture. Two lists, and the uncomfortable one is the more valuable of the two.
Gap
A pain in the top three with no reliever facing it.
This is your next product decision. Either you close it, or you knowingly leave it and say why. In the example: the price is unclear up front, and nothing in the offer answers that.
Idle effort
A service on the left that relates to no recorded pain or gain.
This is your deletion list. It costs money and attention and buys nothing. It is also the harder of the two to accept, because it is usually the part you enjoyed building.
Five mistakes that cost the tool its value
All five produce a canvas that looks finished. That is what makes them expensive: a wrong answer in a tidy layout is harder to question than an empty box.
Filling the canvas in at your desk. What comes out is an orderly presentation of your assumptions. It looks like a result and is not one. The right-hand side belongs in conversations, not in a working session.
Starting on the left. Begin with your own offer and from then on you only look for pains that happen to match it. Right before left is the tool's most important rule and the one broken most often.
Filling all six boxes equally. Thirty-six equally weighted sticky notes are wallpaper, not insight. Without a ranking the fit cannot be checked, because every line appears to carry the same weight.
Writing solution words into the customer profile. "Needs an app" is not a customer job, it is your solution put into the customer's mouth. The job behind it is: know the state of the bike without going to look.
Putting two audiences into one canvas. Commuters and road cyclists have different jobs and opposing pains. Merged, you get an average customer who does not exist and an offer that half serves both.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the Value Proposition Canvas and the Business Model Canvas?
The Business Model Canvas describes the whole company in nine building blocks. The Value Proposition Canvas zooms into exactly two of them, customer segments and value propositions, and breaks each into three boxes. Rule of thumb: one shows how you make money, the other why anyone buys. In practice you sketch the Business Model Canvas first, then go into the Value Proposition Canvas for your most important audience, and use what you find there to correct the blocks on the larger canvas.
Do I need a separate canvas for each audience?
Yes, one canvas per customer segment. As soon as two groups share a canvas, their pains average out into something that is true for neither. If you are unsure whether you have two groups: do they differ in the job they are trying to get done, or only in age and postcode? Only the first case justifies a second canvas.
How do I know whether the fit is real?
Fit is not something you explain, it is something customers confirm, and it arrives in three levels. First, conversations confirm that the pains are real. Then the market shows that people use your offer and pay for it. Finally the numbers show that more comes in than winning the customer costs. Skip the third level and you often end up with a popular offer and no viable business.
How many entries belong in one box?
In the customer profile, five to eight per box at first so nothing important is missing, then cut down to the three strongest pains and the two most important gains. In the value map, only as many entries as can be tied to those marked points, so usually fewer. A full canvas is not a good canvas. A decided one is.
I already have a unique selling proposition. Do I still need the canvas?
The unique selling proposition is one sentence facing outward. The canvas is the work that sentence comes out of. Write the sentence without doing the work and you usually describe what you offer rather than what the customer gets. The other way round, a completed canvas hands you the raw material: the strongest pain and its matching reliever are exactly the two parts that belong in the sentence.
Read next
Get your value proposition checked
The VALUE ANALYST rates how strong the promise behind your offer really is, and the Full package returns a filled-in Value Proposition Canvas for your idea. From € 5.99, in minutes.
Assess my idea →